Analysis of the meeting

Analysis of the meeting in the 3rd of November 2007 of alterglobalist, civil and social movements and tendencies of the CIS countries


At present time Russian internet is discussing of the meeting. We present your enlightened attention several opinions of the participants:


Stanislav Markelov, president of the Institute of Superioroty of Law.

1. The meeting was held in atmosphere of creative chaos: everything and all was taking place by itself, without over-organization. Flexible forms of self-organization are very important.

2. All, who wanted, took chair to speak

3. There was plenty of new people (from Kalmykii, Minska, Uliyanovska, Kazani and other regions), which enjoyed and liked the Meeting.

4. Unfortunately due to financial reasons, not all the C.I.S. states and distant regions of Russia were represented.

5. Catering was properly organized.

6. Due to different length of miscellaneous seminars some participants "hung in pause".

7. It is desirable to enrich the spectrum of positions at such meetings.

8. It is essential not to lose the orientation on diminishing of inter-group conflicts so that these meetings do not transform into platforms of clarification of old painful relations between separate persons and group, but to transform them to constructive logic, while preserving the atmosphere of discussions of such meetings


Darya Mitina, Second secretary of the Central Committee of the Russian Young Communist League (RKSM).

1. It is regretful that the meeting was not properly covered by mass-media.

2. It is necessary to make arrangements with exact known journalists (only 2 journalists were present) before, rather then simply send information to agencies.

3. This public information fault is practically unique. Alost all the rest was a success. The Action was prepared in extremely compressed periods, less than a month (first Organizational Committee (Orgkomitet) - an October 8, The meeting on November 3). The Improvisations sometimes do better, than carefully prepared actions.

4. It is advisable to record all plenary and section seminars (due to multiple requests by those who failed to come to Moscow but want to read the materials in Internet).

5. By the following Forum it is desirable to carry out some work with large partners, that either did not participate at all, or level of their participation was insignificant (VKT trade-union, IKD institute, Teachers' trade unions, left non-parliamentary parties, including unregistered or deregistered).

6. It is necessary to define the level and degree of our participation in preparation of SOCFORUM-2008 Social Forum considering that it would be held on Ukrainian territory. We should send our delegates and representatives to meetings of the Ukrainian Organizational Forum.

7. The database on participants and organizations (based on questionnaires, filled by participants at registrations), should be created and constantly renewed.

8. We should adjust distribution of materials (quite a lot of people do not receive them).



Larisa Ozhogina, "Alternatives" and Mihail Kropotkin, leader of a public enterprise.

1. The meeting was held at the working and what it is important - comradely, brotherly friendly atmosphere.

2. Selection of people for such meetings is not at the proper level. Amongst the participants must be less occasional people but rather those concerned with the real deal. So it is necessary for participants to fill questionnaires about its personal activity before their arrival. But this should not at all mean closeness of the meetings, but rather the principle of increasing of their efficiency.

3. We need a principle: not to criticize other organizations from formal position.

4. At meetings everyone must be greatly and constructively being self-realized.

5. At plenary meeting (the opening) the audience was drowned because of intergroup contacts, the audience did not actively participate. It is necessary to speakers at "open mike" to "keep" the audience.


Lyudmila Bulavka.

1. I think that it was sound! And this not accidentally since it was reached by high quality of the alterglobalists meeting: profound, interesting, discussionable and herewith comradely, on-friendly, rather then hostile.

2. At the meeting there were no "slots", in which, as a rule something small-minded-spiteful live.

3. I liked architecture of the meeting: each of the organizers as in jazz orchestra felt the logic of the Integer and was initiative, trying to backstop each other. There was no fighting for egoistic interests.

4. I Liked that, for instance, the round table on questions of the culture and politics was conducted together by Vlad Tupikin and me. There was no a dictatorship of monistic approach and, besides, Vlad simply helped me in conducting at the most complex moments. He undertook the most difficult part of conduct.

5. I agree with critiques by Larisa Ozhogina that it is necessary to invite real working activists from regions. I offer to implement the principle of the labor participation in alterglobalists meetings: he, who works, arrives. To allow the principle of political representation of organizations is not acceptable. A one, even if he represents an organization nevertheless should previously describe what he personally does on ground. This will prevent at least at some measure penetration careerist and egoist motives in alterglobalist background.

6. We must introduce the principle of financial transparency in organizations of similar meetings, as it was for the first time implemented at this meeting.

7. Sales of any goods at such meetings must be done only with permission of the Organizational Committee of the Forum, since the Forum is responsible. But attempts to use the meeting as platform for their business (I mean not the left papers, of course) were undertaken during the meeting, in particular by one young person, who refused to introduce gimself.

8. I enjoyed very much that the speeches at plenary meeting were on background of jazz music. This is stylish!



Said Gafurov.

1. The meeting showed high efficiency of the given formats: small resources, small facility, very short period and enormous effect.

2. The leaders of the plenary meetings were almost perfect.

3. Effect of size. Probably about 200 people are the most effective number of participants.

We now know empirically that it this form - Working Meeting of Activists and their counsels turned out to be very productive. And we can proudly call it a "Mini-Forum". Excellent form!

4. Sound organization of sections under given space and time, which we had in the restaurant and which we used on 110 %. But number of sections was too little not enough. Sure November in Moscow is exact time for outdoors sections.

5. I am sure, that consider the given form - Working Meeting of Activists we simply do not need to spend our efforts for PR activity with mass-media. We are not "political technologists" We should keep our PR resources for bigger and more open meetings.



Alexander Buzgalin, coordinator of the motion "Alternatives".

1. What is principally important, is that while preparing the meeting all work of the activists was free and not paid or compensated in any form. There was no spirit of business or bureaucracy.

2. After such meetings we should conduct "analysis of the flight" with analysis of our faults and strong points, not only by Organizational Committee, but also by all activists. Here, every vision of each is important.

3. We should make a smart and intelligent report about this meeting for sending out, as well as for Internet sites. The transparency of information is important.

4. For the future it is necessary to organize the well-timed sending out of the materials on preparing of the forum, as well as open for all Internet site.


Each interested person can join this "analysis of the flight". You cab send your own proposals and offers on e-mail:


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Decay Mbt Authority Shoes Consider Your Paradisaic kids shoes in

At Golfbuyitonline we have a fantastic range of both men's and ladies kids shoes in black and white with red Retro Running Shoes . Footjoy Myjoys Shoes With over 72000 combinations to choose from the Footjoy Myjoys customised programme allows you to design your own personal shoe from colour varieties and logos or personalisation with your name or initials embroidered in the heel section. You can even order different size shoes if you have different size feet! Footjoy Icon Golf Shoes If you're looking for the best then Footjoy Icon Golf Shoes are the golf shoes for you. FJ Icon shoes are worn by the world's elite Footjoy professionals who demand the highest level of performance, quality and style. Footjoy Icon Golf Shoes combine both full grain and exquisite calfskin leathers, supported by a performance infused outsole. Footjoy Sport Golf Shoes Combining a Feature Laden Outsole with an unashamedly youthful upper pattern, Footjoy Sport Golf shoes offer new levels of Sport performance. Designed and developed for the player seeking crossover-inspired performance golf shoes. Footjoy Sport Golf Shoes are lightweight and stable whilst providing a Sports look for the younger golfer, and ticks all the boxes for a growing number of golfing fashionistas. Footjoy SYNR-G Golf Shoes Synr-G Shoes by Footjoy are a very stable modern golf shoe offering full breath ability and waterproofness as well as the well known optiflex sole which flexes as you turn through the shot giving better comfort and stability. Top players seeking the best equipment choose Footjoy SYNR-G golf shoes for ultimate stability and motion control. Footjoy LoPro Series Golf Shoes Footjoy LoPro Golf Shoes come with an athletic look and feel. LoPro's provide shoes with a sporty modern appeal for golfers looking for a more casual and comfortable look in their golf shoes. Designed like the low profile casual shoes worn off the golf course, these models offer a familiar easy ride - superb cushioning and incredible comfort. Footjoy AQL Golf Shoes FootJoy AQL Golf Shoe range offers the golfer ultra-lightweight comfort with added stability for all year round play. If you are looking for a Footjoy Golf Shoes that offers great value for money these are great shoes for you. The FJ AQL range is designed for all levels of golfers in all sizes and widths for every type and size of foot. Great shoe, great price and great quality! Footjoy GreenJoy Golf Shoes Footjoy Greenjoy Golf Shoes are a lightweight golf shoe with soft, low maintenance, synthetic uppers. They offer the comfort, fit and styling which has long been established in all FootJoy golf shoes, as well as waterproof performance and outstanding value for money. Footjoy Contour Series Golf Shoes Footjoy Contour Series Golf Shoes offer the ultimate in Comfort and flexibility with a slip last construction. If you're looking for a golf shoes that's like wearing Slippers, then these are the ones for you. Footjoy DryJoy Golf Shoes Footjoy Dryjoy Golf Shoes are 20 years old and are still the number one Golf Shoes worldwide. What more can you sat to that. The #1 all-weather performance brand in golf. DryJoys are the standard of waterproof, performance golf shoes. Footjoy Reelfit Golf Shoes Footjoy Reelfit Golf Shoes are great for those golfers who struggle with laces and your feet expanding. Footjoy Reelfit Golf Shoes offer a BOA lacing system is perfect for you allowing adjustment throughout your round of golf. Footjoy SoftJoy Golf Shoes Footjoy Softjoy Nike Air Max JR are full grain leather upper soft and comfortable golf shoes. There is also a waterproof guarantee of 1 year when you purchase a pare of Footjoy Softjoy Golf Shoes. Classics We have just managed to get our hands on the LAST EVER drop of Footjoy Classic Shoes. It's the end of an Era as these Hand crafted shoes will never be available again. Get your order in now to own a piece of Nike Air Max Destiny History. Air Max Griffey Fury 2012 Mens Shoes in black gray green

I wish to give pass4sure

I wish to give pass4sure latest exam questions special thank for this useful content I really appreciate 642-901 test///N10-004 test///642-845 test///220-602 test this wonderful post.Thanks!

The football sport is really

The football sport is really one of new nfl jerseys the biggest sports in America. Cheap 49ers Jerseys We all love it and it does youth ravens jerseys have a major Baltimore Ravens Jerseys following. That is why you will be able to find the NFL jerseys for all of your favorite team or players everywhere. In this internet era, when everything in the real world is taken into the cyberspace, there are really a lot of NFL jerseys for sale online. Either with collectibles or nike nfl jerseys china for wearing, there are usually cheap nike nfl jerseys separate markets for NFL jerseys online. The main two is the market Ravens Jerseys womens ravens jerseys for the 49ers Jerseys authentic San Francisco 49ers Jerseys NFL jerseys and that for the replica NFL jerseys. However, there is no clear line between them because there are so many types nike nfl jerseys of NFL jerseys and also even the replica NFL jerseys are not duplicated in the same way. nfl jerseys cheap Whether you want to buy the authentic sport jerseys or the replica one, there you will find enough selections online. There are different NFL jerseys for both females and males online. First, when companies start manufacturing NFL jerseys for females, there is a San Francisco 49ers Jerseys Cheap change for women youth 49ers jerseys that female can also watch and play football, but not Cheap Ravens Jerseys mix with males. These NFL jerseys for females come in all different sizes and styles. That is custom ravens jerseys to say, they can Nike 49ers Jerseys fit all different body types as well as anyone’s tastes. These NFL jerseys are printed with team names and colors form all the teams on the NFL. You Baltimore Ravens Jerseys Cheap can buy your NFL jersey themed with your favorite team. Second, as custom 49ers jerseys to those Nike Ravens Jerseys NFL jerseys for males, there are really millions of different types. However, it womens 49ers jerseys is obviously that although they come in different sizes, there is just one style for all. Therefore it is really possible for both men and women to back their team. If you find some signed, limited edition jerseys in some stores online, this will really make you look like an even greater supporter of your favorite team. NFL jerseys sale online is really hot during this season. How could one refuse the home comfort to buy what you want by some way that can save you both energy and money? Many retailers online offer the discount and even a big discount up to forty percent. Also you will find some great NFL jerseys at clearance price or some auction that let you bids. Online you can find everything you need. Just enjoy the football matches wearing the NFL jerseys of your favorite team for supporting and be happy!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.